Finance and economics | Buttonwood

How investors get risk wrong

Contrary to popular wisdom, more volatile stocks do not outperform

Illustration of a man pulling a dollar bill from under a bomb
Illustration: Satoshi Kambayashi

Hire a wealth manager, and one of their first tasks will be to work out your attitude to risk. If you are not sure exactly what this means, the questions are unlikely to help. They range from the inane (“How do you think a friend who knows you well would describe your attitude to taking financial risks?”) to the baffling (“Many television programmes now have a welter of fast whizzing images. Do you find these a) interesting; b) irritating; or c) amusing but they distract from the message of the programme?”). This is not necessarily a sign that your new adviser is destined to annoy you. Instead, it hints at something fundamental. Risk sits at the heart of financial markets. But trying to pin down precisely what it is, let alone how much of it you want and which investment choices should follow, can be maddening.

To get around this, most investors instead think about volatility, which has the advantage of being much easier to define and measure. Volatility describes the spread of outcomes in a bell-curve-like probability distribution. Outcomes close to the centre are always the most likely; volatility determines how wide a range counts as “close”. High volatility also raises the chances of getting an extreme result: in investment terms, an enormous gain or a crushing loss. You can gauge a stock’s volatility by looking at how wildly it has moved in the past or, alternatively, how expensive it is to insure it against big jumps in the future.

This article appeared in the Finance & economics section of the print edition under the headline "Why risk it?"

And they’re off. What could upend America’s election?

From the March 9th 2024 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

More from Finance and economics

How Ukrainians are using the cover of war to escape taxes

“Black grain” infuriates exporters playing by the rules

What campus protesters get wrong about divestment

Will withdrawing money hurt Israel?


Hedge funds make billions as India’s options market goes ballistic

The country’s retail investors are doing less well